Hannah Brown Books

Hannah Brown's Blog

It’s Crazy, But I Wish My Autistic Son Could Be a Soldier

It’s Crazy, But I Wish My Autistic Son Could Be a Soldier

No one envies a soldier’s mother.

The worry. The sleepless nights. The fear that your child will suffer harm, both physical and psychological.

Especially in Israel, where I live, military service is tough and dangerous.

So, how is it that I find myself envying parents whose children are soldiers?

Danny at his pre-military training camp.

Danny at his pre-military training camp.

It’s because my son Danny, who turns 19 soon and who was diagnosed with autism at the age of 3, can’t serve. He can’t be drafted and he can’t volunteer. Although just last week there was a news item about a high-functioning young man with autism distinguishing himself in the Israel Defense Forces military intelligence unit, Danny needs too much supervision to be a part of the army.


His school has participated in pre-military training programs, where they did all kinds of workouts (without weapons, of course) in the desert and wore uniforms. He loved it. But even though there is a unit in the army where people with special needs serve, they are better able to focus, follow directions and understand abstract concepts than my son.

Danny can’t even cross the street by himself, because he is too easily distracted to take note of oncoming traffic and the colors of stoplights. He can talk more easily about a beloved cat that died 12 years ago than he can about what he did this morning.

Of course I don’t want him to be in the kind of danger he would be in if he served in the military and I have nothing but compassion for parents who worry about their soldier children every day and night.

In addition, I am on the left and have great political misgivings about what the IDF directs its soldiers to do much of the time and where it sends them.

But not being part of the military in Israel is to be out of the mainstream of society in a more decisive way than anything that has come before for Danny. All Israelis, male and female, are drafted (or volunteer if they have certain medical conditions, such as epilepsy, that prevent them from being drafted), and serve two to four years, except for most ultra-Orthodox Jews and Arabs. It is a nearly universal experience here, a much more common rite of passage than going to college is in America.

We are neither ultra-Orthodox nor Arab, and every time I meet people and they ask me if I have kids and how old they are, the inevitable follow-up question is about what Danny is doing in the army.

When I tell them he isn’t in the army and why, there is usually polite silence.

The truth is that for Danny, not being in the army is not a problem. Although he is fully bilingual in English and Hebrew, can read and write and has a phenomenal memory, he doesn’t seem to fully understand that he is an adult. At synagogue, he finds himself drawn to much younger children, and seems to see them as his peers. On some level, of course, he does realize he has grown, but any time I try to have a conversation with him about it, he cuts me off, saying, “I don’t want to talk about it.” He knows, and he doesn’t know.

I also know, and don’t know.

When I wrote a novel, If I Could Tell You, about four families whose children are diagnosed with autism at the same time, I deliberately chose not to set it here in Israel, because I was not prepared to deal with the issue of military service. I guess even then I didn’t want to think about it.

In an article in The New York Times Magazine last July, Ruth Padawer wrote about children with autism who eventually lose their diagnosis. What many people got from that article was that approximately 10 percent of children with autism grow out of the diagnosis. What I got out of it was that 90 percent didn’t, even when they received identical treatment to the 10 percent who did, exactly the kind of treatment that Danny has gotten.

Even the experts quoted in the article couldn’t say why things turned out this way.

The publication of this article came at a very difficult time for me. There were many changes at Danny’s school because of the Israel-Gaza war last summer, as teachers were called for military reserve duty. For a complicated set of reasons, the afternoon program at his school was closed for the duration of the war, and all the changes were very stressful for him. His tantrums became much more frequent. When an 18-year-old has tantrums like a toddler, it’s much harder to handle. I was still dealing with the paperwork to become his legal guardian. Reading about the lucky 10 percent couldn’t have been more discouraging.

I often thought of the 2009 University of Wisconsin Study, the one that showed that mothers of children with autism experience levels of stress comparable to combat soldiers. In my opinion, so do many people with autism. Their challenging behavior often stems from fear, from terror of changes or the unknown.

As hard as this period was for me, it was much harder for Danny, and that was what hurt the most.

It was a particularly crazy time for me to wish that Danny could have been part of the military. Yet I did, intensely so. It was hard for me to talk to friends with children Danny’s age, who had just joined or were about to join the army. My friends with 18-year-olds back in America, where I grew up and where Danny was born, were helping their kids pack for college.

But in the end, I realized that the green uniform was just a symbol for what I wanted for Danny: the chance to live an independent life, one where he would be able to make his own choices and live the life he wanted. I still hope he will achieve a measure of independence someday.

That’s really what most parents want for their children. And even though he can’t express it, on some level, I think that’s what Danny wants for himself. All the habits that go along with his autism, the need for routine and repetition, are ways that he soothes himself and keeps himself going. Hearing the same stories over and over helps him, and so does looking at snapshots every night of all the cats we’ve ever owned. He is often scared, as a soldier might be, and he is just as brave. He faces a tough fight every day, and I am proud of him.


Posted in: Huffington Post, News

Leave a Comment: (1) →

1 Comment

  1. Walter Solomon February 18, 2017

    Very moving


Leave a Comment